Critique Of The Gay Marriage Is Good For America - 1445 Words

Critique of Sullivan’s â€Å"Why Gay Marriage is Good for America† Debates about gay marriage continue to simmer within American public discourse, though much of the more heated rhetoric has calmed since the earliest efforts to legalize same-sex marriage succeeded in numerous states. These debates have spanned many topics, ranging from religion to politics and beyond. Andrew Sullivan, a prominent gay and self-described conservative political commentator, addressed one angle of the issue in his July 19, 2011 Newsweek Magazine article â€Å"Why Gay Marriage is Good for America.† Through a mixture of personal reflection, social commentary, and political argumentation, Sullivan’s article is less a defense of gay marriage than it is a defense of the idea that gay marriage is compatible with conservative political values. Although Sullivan makes a good case for his position in the article, his argument is ultimately under-developed; the lengthy personal reflections serve to reinforce a relatively minor point in the context of the larger argu ment, shifting focus away from the more relevant portions of the argument. Much of the first half of â€Å"Why Gay Marriage is Good for America† describes the author’s personal experience as a child growing up with the knowledge that he was different, eventually realizing that his feelings of being an outsider arose from his homosexuality. Sullivan writes, describing his pre-pubescent realization that he was not like other men he knew, that â€Å"I knew one thingShow MoreRelatedHomosexuality in Same Love by Macklemore with Ryan Lewis and Mary Lambert1006 Words   |  5 Pagesagainst the issues of discrimination, gay rights, and marriage equality that we see in todays era. He uses two fallacies in the song, but Macklemore’s use of the three rhetorical appeals of ethos, pathos, and logos in his song â€Å"Same Love,† have a great level of success in proving the importance of gay rights and marriage equality. Right away Macklemore establishes his credibility and knowledge, ethos, by stating, When I was in the third grade I thought that I was gay, Cause I could draw, my uncle wasRead MoreNegative Effects Of Prostitution1376 Words   |  6 Pagesneeds outside the suite, because it will be a violation, they need to be inside their business room. It’s good that way because it’s safe they would know their client name and face and they wouldn’t worry about being forced to do anything they don’t want to do. Congress should have laws saying that they will be protected if gone beyond any extinct they will get help, not penalize them; what good does that do? Another solution is that they need to provide counseling and because not everyone wants toRead MoreDo Public Debates Help Or Hurt Candidate Success?868 Words   |  4 Pagesof America, it was their first presentation of John F. Kennedy. When Kennedy, the 42-year-old Irish-American Junior Senator, was approached abo ut the idea of debating his political opponent on television, he agreed instantaneously. While on the other hand, Vice President Nixon had just concluded 12 days of hospitalization for a mishap knee injury. Richard Nixon’s sweaty, pale and underweight, appeared sickly, while on the other hand a glowing Kennedy, self –confident, and not to mention good looksRead MoreA Native American Who Demonstrated Homosexual Tendencies1945 Words   |  8 Pagestheir nature, two-spirited people were made religious leaders and teachers in the society. They also served various unique roles in the society and their marriages were legitimate. However, the onset of Christianity and foreign influence in North America led to the spread of homophobic notions and the decline of the â€Å"two-spirit† tradition. Later on, gay and lesbian activists detested the use of use of the term â€Å"berdache.† Instead, they preferred to be called â€Å"two-spirit† persons. Finally, th ese protestsRead MoreA Social Critique Of The Judgment Of Taste1661 Words   |  7 Pagessociety; especially those that were diverse and delicate in the ways of how they were transferred. As well as how social order were maintained throughout the time of their existence. (Bourdieu) Bourdieu is best known for his book Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgment of Taste. Being deemed the sixth most important sociological work of the twentieth century by the International Sociological Association (ISA). (Bourdieu) argues that judgments of taste are acts of social positioning. Along the journeyRead MoreEvery Generation Is Defined By Something. Baby Boomers1417 Words   |  6 Pages† While we have been striving to be a more tolerant and accepting society, which is a good thing, we have inadvertently created a bubble in which sensitive subjects are untouchable and any slight can be interpreted as harassment. Millennials are a generation more tolerant than previous generations. We open our arms to immigrants, title nine, gay marriage, and interracial dating. We believe diversity is a good thing, but lately, it seems like that doesn t include a diversity of thought. While strivingRead MoreThe Reality Of The Lgbtq Community1404 Words   |  6 PagesI analyze these two pop culture productions because they are reflections of the current social-political setting in North America. Constituting and diminishing social boundaries, pop culture has wide-reaching influence to generate new sets of values and ideals in audiences (Fedorak 2009). Originating in mainstream pop culture, discourses of gender and sexuality The Kids Are All Right and The Fosters support homonormative politics, which privileges some lesbian mothers as intelligible over othersRead MoreLegalization of Same Sex Marriage9779 Words   |  40 PagesTHE LEGALIZATION OF SAME SEX MARRIAGE AS ASSESED BY CITHM STUDENTS S.Y. 2011-2012 A Thesis Presented to the Faculty of the College of International Tourism And Hospitality Management LYCEUM OF THE PHILIPPINES UNIVERSITY In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Bachelor of Science in Tourism By Ang, Dianne Marie M. Bayot, Donalynne B. October 2011 CHAPTER 1 THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND INTRODUCTION    In our generation today, homosexualsRead MoreThe kitchen is arguably the last battle – ground for reproduction of gender relations in the western world. Discuss.2158 Words   |  9 Pagesthere. The low-calorie food is seen as feminine food in opposition to the high – calorie food or meat as masculinity food. Clark (2013:235) Swenson (2013: 140, 145) The sine qua non (an essential condition , the thing is absolutely necessary) of a good family relations is a joint dinner prepared wholly by the women. The double message is that the woman should cook to maintain traditional unity of family (woman in feeding) and that is her responsibility. Swenson (2013:145), El – Tom (2014) She mustRead MoreDecision Making Is At The Core Of The United States Supreme Court2095 Words   |  9 Pagesthat the decisions in the aforementioned cases show an overall rightward shift of the court with unprecedented severity. While Toobin believes the Roberts Court as a whole is increasingly making more conservative decisions, he focuses much of his critique on Chief Justice John Roberts. Toobin believes he is the catalyst for inciting the dramatic move to the right that the court has seemingly made during his tenure as chief justice. The case that Toobin believed would provide his argument and thus